# Eΐ_ւ̋^Oi7j`ȑʇD`/ij

́A"Relativity"ɊւẮA_̈ȏɐaȑOȌA܂ł̗jI^
ɋNiƂAȂł͂"Anti-Relativity"̈lɂȂĂ鎄
킹Ă炤ȂAǂāuȂ́v"Holy Theory"Ă܂̂s
vcłȂȂȂājACOTCg𓖂悤ɂȂA̒ŔmȂ
iȂƂ܂œ{TCgł͖ڂɂƂȂ́jɂđI
ŏЉĂĂ̂łAł̋^₪Sĉ𖾂ł킯
͂ȂAɌĂƂłB

AFXƑ̈̕ӌ𒲂ׁAlĕ͂Aweb_łЉ
Ă̂̂𖔁ANǂĔ܂BɋCɂȂ̂ł̂ł
̂ŏЉĂ܂iMysterious Rivision of Einstein's Theory)B

́AEinstain"Special Relativity"1905N̍ŏ̃hCc̃IWiłƁA
̌ɏopłƂɈ̏dvȑ_ƂƂłB
܂lȂƁACɂĂ܂ȂƂȂ̂łEEE

́AAlberto A. Martinezƌ"American Journals of Physics,Volume 73,Issue 5,
pp.452-454(2005)"ŌyĂ邻łAhCcIWî܂܉p󂷂
ƁA

@Consider a coordinate system in which the equations of Newtonian
@mechanics hold

@ij[g͊w̕ێĂWnl悤j

Ƃ邾Ȃ̂ɁǍォoꂽpłł́A

@a system of coordinates on which the equations of Newtonian
@mechanicss hold good, i.e., to the first approximation

@ij[g͊w̕܂AȂ킿ߎێ
@@ĂWnj

ƉMuCvĂƂƂłB

web_̒҂₻̌ɂȂĂMartinezƌuɂĂ
̂
v킩ł傤H
ނ̌_́AEinstein̏Cł͖A"person(s) unkonwn"ɂȂ
̂ł
ƂƂłBMartinezƌ

There is no evident that Einstein added it.
iEinsteinƌ؋͖j

ƏĂ邻łAweb_̒҂͂̕łƂ̂ƂłB
NȂ̂߂ɂĈł傤HMartinez

@Presumably, this specific footnote was added to harmonize the
@pertinent sentence with special relativity, which revises many
@equations of Newton's mechanics.

@i炭A̓ʂȕ͑̃j[gύXꑊΐ
@@_Ƃ̓K؂ɕ𒲘a邽߂ɉꂽj

ƏĂ邻łB

web_̒҂́Â킸̏CAۂɂ͘_̂concept
ςĂ܂Ă悤Ȏ|A܂킿A"Special Relativity"̂"SR1""SR2"Ƃ
SɈقȂo[WƂƂ咣Ă܂B
āÂƂ́Aweb essayƂFred HutchsonƂ̎wEɒʂ悤łB
́̕A

@Newton's math is one thing,Einstein's math is a scond thing,
@and the math of the bridge between the two is a third thing.

@The bridge had noting in common with Newton's math or
@Einstein's math.

@ij[g̐w͈̂́AACV^C̐w͓Ԗڂ̂́A
@@̓Ԃn鐔wÔ̂łB
@@̋̓j[g̐wƃACV^C̐ẘԂŋʂ
@@͉Ȃj

ƂA

@Where does the mathematical bridge come from?
@It comes from the science establishment.

@i̐wIˋ͂ǂ痈̂H
@@͉ȊwgD痈Ă̂łj

Ǝ咣Ă邻łBāÁ̕A

@The two can never touch. why not? Because the structure of
@math in the bridge is alien to Newton's math.The bridge is an
@artificial consturuct and an illusion. It is bone to fool the
@bulldogs.

@i̓͌ĐGꂠƂ͖BȂHɂ鐔w\
@@j[gwɂƂĈٍlłB̋͐lH\ł
@@茶e(illusion)łB̓uhbOM鍜łj

ƌA

@I was almost fooled.But lest I be overly embrrased, many
@scientists are fooled by their own trick.

@i͖wǋMĂBȂAЂǂfĂ
@@͉̂Ȋw҂ނ玩g̃gbNŋMĂ̂ł͂ȂƁj

ƊSQĂ邻łB

ŁAweb_̎̕咣́A

@SR1 means the theory that Einstein was dealing with was really
@Poincare's theory or rather his confused misunderstanding of
@Poincare's theory

@iSR1[EinsteiñhCc̍ŏ̌_̂]̓ACV^C
@@ۂɃ|AJ̗_܂͂ނA|AJ̗_̔ނ̍
@@뗝_ł邱ƂӖj

āA

@While SR2 means a theory that was never property defined, and
@is a confused mess, because the 1905 paper starts from Newtonian
@physics and never clearly explains why Newtonian physics should
@be abandoned and replaced by another theory(SR2), and never
@clearly explains what is the different between those theories.

@iASR2[Oq̉płŏCꂽ]͌ēK؂ɒ`ꂽ
@@ł͂Ȃ_łAȂȂA1905N̘_̓j[gw
@@n߂Ă̂ɌĂȂj[gŵĂđ̗_(SR2)
@@û𖾔ɐĂ炸A̗_̊Ԃ̑Ⴊ
@@ɂČĖ炩ȐĂȂ)

Ƃ̂łB

̌㕶A͂܂ɂɁuȂȂ̂HvƂâłB
Ƃ̗_ɈaĂ錴݂Ȃ̂Ɋւ錾Ɖ͂ł
̂ŏʑЉ܂B

vɁAEinsteiň͎_̓j[g͊wɔŴƎv
̂łÁAx҂̉Ȋw҂́uꂪԈႢłvƂɋCtĂ
ꕶtƂƂłBςAėȁ͎Ȏv
݂ł͂ȂƂƂłBAAsvcȂ̂́uȂ܂łĎx̂
낤HvƂƂȂłAcOȂ܂A܂ł͒TłĂ܂B
ȂALFred HutchsonƂ̍ŌɎ"many scientists are fooled by
their own trick"Ƃ̂́AĂauł̂vƍȂ
ŉ]w҂Ȃǂ̕Xɐ̂łBȂ킿Auẘb
_IɏoĂ̂Ȃǂł͖APɁwMĂ邾xłH

łB

ƂŁAOqweb_҂GĂPoincaré̌łAIɂ͂܂䂪c
Ă܂B́AIɂȂ"Einstein Pagiarized Poincaré"Ƃ{oła
{łƂŁA{TCgłbɂȂĂƂɂ܂B̖{̍҂
͂Ȃ悤łACOTCgłᔻĂ󂯂܂B

ǵAPoincaré̘_ĂȂ̂łǁACɂȂĂ͓̂lg
̒kbƂłoėȂƂȂłBėBAlbgŖڂɂ
̂́Auϑi߂΁AȂȂ\vƂ悤Ȏ|̂̂炢
BƂ낪A"Pagiarized Poincaré"ƂƂlꂽ̂́A_
ۂɐ݂̑̂̂ł邱Ƃ킩܂B
AOqweb_̒҂̓_TCg(the general science journal)ɓe
Ă̂Œm܂iRewriting of the history of special thory of relativity)B

ɈpĂ̂́AȊwj̐Ƃ炵Yves GingrasƂ

@"The collective construction of scentific memory:The Einstein-Poincaré
@conneciton and its discontents, 1905-2005"

Ƃ_̂̂łB

̘_̒ŁA

@The debate on the role of Poincaré in the emergence of relativity
@theory has been particularly hot in France where amateurs have
@published books claiming that Einstein Pagiarized Poincaré

@iA}`AEinsteinPoincaré𓐍삵Ƃᔻ̖{ołꂽ
@@tXŁuΐ_v̏oɂPoincaré̖ɊւfBx[g
@@ɔMȂĂj

Ƃ܂B
ܘ_̂ƁA"Relativists"(="Einsteinians")͖ߍ񂾂łi_Ȃ
Ƃ̂炷ΔڋƎv̂łǁAssȂƂ͂Ă悤
łˁBx͒mĂ邩炱ٓ_ߍ񂾂̂ȁHjAuȊwjv̐
ƂƂĂ͖łȂ悤łˁB{́AA}`A̖{ōXj𒲂ׂȂ
Ƃ̂͂ǂƂȂ̂HƖ₢̂łǂˁB

Sɂ͂킩Ȃ݂łA܂ŉBĂƂقƂǒm炳
ĂȂƂĂ܂B
ǂAEinsteinƔނ"Special Relativity"ꋓɑSEŗLɂȂ̂́A1915N
ɔ\"General Relativity"1919NŎwEEddington̜ӓIϑ
\󂯂Ă炵łBAA܂ł͕cĂȂ炵̂łǁAhCc
EinsteinhƃtXLorentz-Poincaréh̘_݂͂łB́AA
Olivier DarrigolƌlPoincaré-theoryEinstein's theoryƂtheory
ƂqׁAXɂ"peace treaty"Ƃ\gĂ邱ƂłB
ǂA͂AOɒׂŐGꂽ悤1910N㓖A"Relativity"
"Lorentz-Einstein Theory"Ə̂Ă̂͊ԈႢȂ悤łBPoincaréLorentz
ꏏɌĂłB܁APoincaré́ȗȐwҁv̈lłˁB

ȂAOq1919N̏o󂯂āAEinsteinɏW܂߂ɂ
"peace treaty"IȂ̂ĉĂ܂̂A1920NtXŘ_

"anti-Semitic"i_`j̕ƂłBǁAEinsteiniansɂ܂
pĂ܂悤łˁBvɁAȌAɐÓA"Anti-Einstein' Relativity"
ҁ"anti-Semitic"Ǝ͎͈Ⴄ̂Ɍ`A]CɂȊw҂̔Ό_
"Einsteinians"͗}킯łBȎ݂͌ɂ͒m炳Ă܂B

ɁA{I"science"ł͂ȂA{A"science"Ƃ͖֌WȂƂōRA
܂_ɍ킹"Einsteinians"tƂƂłB

Aweb_҂wEĂ邱ƂłA܂ŒׂĂ킩̂ɁA
ȊwjƂ́uƂȂ`vɊׂāAuȊwj̏v瓦悤ŁA

@Gingras' belief is that historians should not deal with such history
@problems.

iGingras̐MÓAjw҂͂̂悤ȗjׂł͂ȂƂ
@Ƃłj

ƂA

@Ofen I hear from scientists that science is a self-correcting process.
@Well who corrects these mistake?

@i΂΁A͉Ȋw҂AȊwhȏCvZX̂̂łƕB
@@ł́Aꂪ̉߂̂Hj

Ǝ咣Ă܂B

lbgł͐Ƃł͂ȂƎv"Einsteinians"̒ɁA

@uEinsteinPoincaréłȂŌ̈𐬂̂v

Ƃ悤ȕىǂ̂̂ڂɂƂ܂Ał͂ȂāA

@uPoincaré͐wƂ䂦ɁAillegalhypothesis܂œݍ
@@Ȃ̂Bw̓ӂłȂEinstein͂̊_𕽋C
@@œ݉zv

Ƃ悤ȋt咣܂B

ȑOAǂŗ҂̐wI͂̑_ɐGꂽ̂ڂɂƂ܂A
؂݂̂ȂŘ_IɍlÁA͂A҂̎咣̕ɕグ
v̂łBāA{̑OiŏqׂƂlƁAꂪɂ͐fƎv
̂łB

Ȃ݂ɁAmȂ̂łAEinstein1913Nɕs{ӂǐEؗ
Ɋ]ĂwɃgo[ꂽłB
āA6Nɂ͈u_vɋP킯łˁB
ŁȂ͎złȂ̂łAEinstein1913N͈̓ǐEł
ȂA1919NȑO͎x҂͂܂A܂̎҂킯łB
ꋓɖlȂAʎs̑́A"Hero"`܂AБ
ɔȊw҂͂łAS͂ǂĂ

@̎EEinsteinLȐwҁEPoincaréiobNLorentz)

ƂȂ͕̂KRÎ܂B

̈Ӗł́A"Einsteinians"uƐMŐFXȕẘ{("Holy
Theory"jƎvł͔ł傤AEinsteinɂ͍KAtɁA
20Inwɂ͑ρusKvȗjȂƎv̂łB

͖{AȊwɁulԂ̍DvuIvu͓IvȖ{Iɂ͉ȊwƂ͖Ȃ
̂邱Ƃɂ͑唽΂łAn̉Ȋw͂Íʂ荞łĂ
͎łBłA"Relativity"uȊẅÍjv́uԁvƋĂ
܂
@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@if14/8j
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
i⑫j
{AȂvĉ߂Ă̕⑫łB
́AʍŁuw_xw_x͎󂯓ȂvƏ肵Ă܂ǁA
̒ɉ萶"Special Relativity"ɑ΂邻́Av񂷂

@ÓT͊wij[g͊wjƂIړ_
@̑Ŝǂɂ̂H

Ƃ^₾킯łB
ʍłłA̓IɌ΁A

@ȂAuԁE̎ړxՓIEsϓIłvƂƂ
@uKCϊvX^[gāAƂ͊SɕIɖ
@uԁE̎ړxǏIvłƂ"Special Relativity"
@oł̂H

ƂƂłBȂ킿A҂͊SɕIɖĂTOłAu҂̊Ԃ
́wIړ_xȂǂǂɂȂȂvƂvłBƒ[IɌȂ΁A

@Ȋw҂́Auł͋ߎIɃj[g͊w藧vƌA
@͒PȂwwIߎx̘bł傤HŁÁww_xłȂA
@w_x̂͂BIɍ{I̈قȂ闼҂̊Ԃ́uI
@A
vȂǂǂɂ̂AȂȂ

ƂsM킯łB
̂Ƃ́Aȕɍl͎̂ȂƎv肵̂łAs̖{o
ĂƂ̂Ƃł炳̃TCgL̃^CgƒgڂɂA܂ɁA
ʂ̂咣Au̗_́iwRȊwx𖳎jwwIgbNxiȊO
łȂjvƍlĂ邱ƂɈӂ̂łB

AꂶAuȂẢȊw҂̒ɂwEȂ̂Hv
Ƃ^Esvc̒ɂ܂B
ŁAׂĂ݂ƁALorentźAꕔŌ`ė悤ȁuۂȂǌĒE
ł炸vAUusӁv̗ŁAĂ钆ł͗BuwgbN
ĂƂbڂɂ܂BǂAǂuwIgbNvȂ̂̓IwE
Ƃb͕Ă܂i܁AɌ킹Ă炦΁A1903Niځj
oꂽLorentz ether theory͂Ȃ̂́A͂AȂposutulate𐔊w

A1905N̘_óAmEinstein

@etherȂǍlȂĂLorentzϊ͓oł
@ˁiÎ~jG[eȂǂȂ

ƎvA咣Ă悤łǁi܂ŊɑOɏoꂽLorent ether theory
āApoincarěȂǂ̌_oƂŖĂ̂ł͂Ȃ
v̂łAʍŏЉĂ悤ɁAǂAEinsteingGeneral Relativity\z
̉ߒŁA܂A̕B̎wEȂǂABȕ\悤łǁA"ether"Ƃ
AuԂemptył͂ȂA炩mediumŏ[Ăvphilosophyς炵
̂łǁAA̕BA"Special Relativity"oEinstein̎vlɏ]A
uG[e͔ے肳ꂽAG[eȂǂȂvƊ拭ɐMłƂƂ͂ȂȂ
AāẢ݂Ȋw҂ɂLorentzϊ̓o@Einsteiň_ƈقȂ̂
ȂƂƂlĂ݂ƁA͂A{OŏЉ悤ȂƂł͂
Ǝv̂łBȂ킿A

@݁A"Special Relativity"ƂċĂ̂Einstein
@IWî̂ł͂ȂAʂ̉ȊwҒBIɍւ
@̂낤

ƂƂłBȂAȂƂ̂łAɎĂ悤ɁA1887N
Michelson-Morley experimentȗẢȊwEɂɑ΂āA܂Lorentz
Lorentz ether TheoryƂĂ19ȈI20ȈɈ̉ߘ_o
łBȂA႟AbetterȐ͂ƌ΂oȂ킯łB
ȕ͋C18NԂƂ̂́A炭͓̉Ȋw҂ɂƂĂ͉}ςYĂ̂ł
ȂƎv܂BɁu΁`vƏoĂ̂̔AJf~YEɂEinstein
̂܂ŉȊwEł͈ʏ펯݂ɂȂĂ"ether"ȂƂvI_
łBAŏI_Lorentz ether theoryƓu[cϊvAĊɓ
̎嗬h̊ԂŎɏnuԂ̒xA̒ZkvĂƂ
ƂāA傫ȏՌ󂯂Ȋw҂ꂽ̂ƍl̂͂Ȃl
ł͂ȂƎv̂łBAނ̓AJf~YȊw҂łARȂ瓖̉Ȋw
ɂ͏\nmĂ͂łAfl̎ĂAeƂEinsteiň_
̂܂܂ł͂ƂvāAnl̏łł邾Ƃ͗Ȃ͈͂ł̍IȏC
ǉ̂Œûł͂ȂƎv̂łistudentւ̍u`Ƃ
ŁjBǁAwhich is better?Einstein̏oĂ̂́uTvvIĂ悭
ΐn̂݋Ă"Special Relativity"Ƃ̂ł͂ȂƎv
̂łBA1919NEdingtońu䂪߂ꂽvϑʕ񍐂ɂAfBA̐`
`Einsteinq[[ɖo߂ɁA^͉BĂ܂̂ł
ȂƎv܂BāAu悭bȂ`vƎv̂łB

FXƉẲȊw҂̔ȂǂĂ܂ƁA{R[i[ōĎOᔻĂ悤ɁA
ƂƁAȊw҂

@reality藝_̃GKgD

XɂA_̃GKg̑Oɂ́uvł܂Ȃ킿yĂ܂
䂦̂ł͂ȂAvɁẢȊwmEZpł͑ɔނ̏L̎v
𖞑悤ȒmboĂAuƂł̖ŊvƂقƂ

ŁẢȊw҂̐S̒܂ŒmȂ㐢̊w҂́uł̂vƂāA
studentsɋAstudentw҂ɂȂĎstudentsɋƂ`łƂ
Ƃł͂Ȃł傤HǁAstudents͋^OɖĂ܂Ă̂ł͂Ǝv̂
Bꂽw҂̂łEEEB炱AuvyĂ̂ł
Ȃł傤HiƂAAJf~YȊw"Holy Theory"ɂȂĂ䂦
uvȂǂƂl΂Ȃ̂ł͂ȂƎȂv̂łj
ȂAuȂvu^IvȉȊw҂ɂ킯ŁABĂ܂
ǁA_aȗAQPI̍Ɏ܂łPOONȏr؂邱ƂȂȁXƉȊw
҂ClaimƂjÎłB
ŁA͂́AƓA_̘_IƂ̗_芪Einsteinians
iΐ_w҂▣ꂽȊwҁAstudentsĵȂĂusvȌ䂦ɕK
RIȂ̂Ǝv̂łBif15/1j @@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@

ڎɖ߂